top of page
Aditya Ighe

A Middle Order Dilemma: Sarfaraz Khan and Suryakumar Yadav's Quest for India's Test Squad

Sarfaraz Khan and Suryakumar Yadav fighting for middle order spot in India's Test squad?Tournaments playing ahead of India's Test squad announcement against Bangladesh.


Suryakumar Yadav to play Buchi Babu tournament and Duleep Trophy |  Walking Wicket (Images_ ©bcci_X)
Suryakumar Yadav to play Buchi Babu tournament & Duleep Trophy (Images: ©BCCI/X)

As India gear up for a demanding Test season, including a crucial series against Australia, the competition for spots in the middle order is heating up. The debate over who should solidify their place in India's Test XI is centred around two highly talented cricketers: Sarfaraz Khan and Suryakumar Yadav. With four Test series lined up this year, including the prestigious Border-Gavaskar Trophy, the stakes couldn’t be higher.


The upcoming Duleep Trophy and Buchi Babu tournaments will play a critical role in the selection process, providing these players with a platform to further their cases. But will these domestic competitions be enough for either of them to secure a spot?


Sarfaraz Khan: Ranji Trophy Powerhouse

Sarfaraz Khan has become synonymous with domestic cricket excellence, especially in the Ranji Trophy. Over the past few seasons, his numbers have been staggering. No other batter has scored more runs at a higher average than Sarfaraz. The 26-year-old Mumbai batter has mustered 2,466 runs in the last three Ranji Trophy editions at an average of 123.3. He has 10 hundreds in 27 innings. His overall first-class career is even more impressive, with 4,112 runs at an astonishing average of 68.5, including 14 centuries and as many fifties.


His ability to play long innings has been the hallmark of his game. He’s often the backbone of Mumbai's batting lineup, guiding his team through challenging situations. Sarfaraz’s technique is well-suited for the longer format. His patience and ability to build an innings make him an ideal candidate for the Test side.


In the recent Buchi Babu tournament, Sarfaraz carried his form forward, scoring 232 runs in five innings, including a crucial century in the semi-finals. His performances have once again highlighted his hunger for runs and his consistency at the domestic level. However, the question remains: Can Sarfaraz translate his domestic success into international cricket?


The challenge will be adapting to the conditions in Australia, where pitches offer more pace and bounce than those in India. Sarfaraz’s technique will be tested against the likes of Pat Cummins, Josh Hazlewood, and Mitchell Starc. While his domestic record is impeccable, his ability to face top-tier international bowlers on unfamiliar pitches remains unproven. This is where the upcoming domestic tournaments become crucial. His performance there could make or break his chances.



India vs England, Rajkot Test_ Sarfaraz Khan scored back-to-back fifties in debut test match _ Walking Wicket (Images_ ©BCCI_Twitter)
Sarfaraz Khan scored back-to-back fifties in debut test match (Images: ©BCCI/X)
Suryakumar Yadav: The X-Factor

In contrast to Sarfaraz’s classical approach, Suryakumar Yadav brings flair and aggression to the table. His rise in international cricket has been meteoric, especially in white-ball formats. In T20Is, Suryakumar has already scored over 2,432 runs at an average of 42.7 and a strike rate of 168.72, including four centuries. His ability to play innovative shots and score quickly has made him one of the most exciting players to watch.


However, Suryakumar’s Test career is still in its infancy, with only one game under his belt. In the first-class arena, his record is solid but not as prolific as Sarfaraz's. He has accumulated 5,628 runs at an average of 43.62, including 14 centuries and 29 fifties.


Suryakumar’s involvement in the Duleep Trophy is seen as an opportunity for him to cement his place in the Test side. His aggressive mindset could be an asset in Test cricket, particularly against a bowling attack like Australia’s, where counter-attacking could shift the momentum in India’s favour.


However, this same aggression might be a double-edged sword. Test cricket demands patience and the ability to grind out tough periods, especially in conditions like those in Australia. Suryakumar’s challenge will be to balance his natural attacking instincts with the need for stability. If he can master this, his inclusion could provide India with a dynamic option in the middle order.



Duleep Trophy and Buchi Babu Tournament: Platform for Selection?

The Duleep Trophy and Buchi Babu tournaments have always been critical in shaping the Indian Test squad, and this year is no exception. The focus will be on how Sarfaraz and Suryakumar perform. The selectors will be looking for consistency, temperament, and the ability to handle pressure—qualities that are vital for succeeding in Test cricket, especially against a team like Australia.


Sarfaraz’s consistent run-scoring and experience in the domestic circuit make him a strong contender for the middle order. His performances in these tournaments will need to reaffirm his ability to step up to the international level. On the other hand, Suryakumar’s ability to change the course of the game with his aggressive batting could sway the selectors if he can prove his mettle in the longer format.


India's upcoming Test series will be a test of character, not just for the team but for the individuals competing for a spot in the playing XI. Sarfaraz Khan and Suryakumar Yadav offer unique qualities. While Sarfaraz brings reliability and consistency, Suryakumar brings flair and potential for game-changing innings.


The final decision will come down to what the team management prioritises: the stability that Sarfaraz brings or the explosive potential of Suryakumar. All eyes will be on these two players as they strive to secure their place in India's Test squad.


The competition is fiercer than ever, and the Duleep Trophy and Buchi Babu tournaments will be the battleground where these players make their final bids for selection. Whether it’s Sarfaraz’s relentless run-scoring or Suryakumar’s ability to inject energy into the innings, both have the talent to make a significant impact. The question is who will seize their moment when it matters most? 


Comments


bottom of page